ITC has this great cash engine called Tobacco. I dug a little bit into the published 2015 results to see how ITC was using its cash.
There is good news and bad news. Bad news — Cash from Cigarettes which generated ~180%+ ROC is being used to fund FMCG and Hotels business where if the ROC is ~1% in 2015. 90% of the additional capital in ITC went into FMCG or the Hotels business. While one might argue that FMCG will make money in the long run, the hotels choice is a bizarre one as it is cyclical and a low return business. Also, they paid 500 Crores for a property in Goa that is being challenged in the courts right now. Was 2015 an anomaly on how much capital went to hotels or will this be a trend? While one might hope a more prudent allocation in the future, it is something one definitely must be concerned about. Also, a clear road to profitability on FMCG will help as well. Good News — 700 Crores out of the 1,500 Crores that were invested came from other parts of the balance sheet like deferred taxes, better TWC etc. Essentially only 900 Crores or 10% of net profit went into capital for in all FMCG and Hotels. Glass half full or half empty?
All Numbers in Crores INR | |||
ITC Last 12 Month Net Profit | 9765 | ||
Depreciation | 1027 | ||
Owners Earnings Before Capex | 10792 | ||
Dividends | 5621 | ||
Net of Dividends | 5171 | ||
Additional Capital Employed | % of Capital Employed | 2014-2015 ROC of Segments | |
Capital Employed in Cigarettes | 121 | 8% | 183% |
Capital Employed in FMCG | 632 | 40% | 0.8% |
Capital Employed in Hotels | 769 | 48% | 1.1% |
Capital Employed in Agri | -79 | -5% | 44.1% |
Capital Employed in Papers | 110 | 7% | 17.0% |
Capital Employed in Others | 41 | 3% | 32.6% |
Total Capital Into Business | 1594 | 31% | |
Net Capital Left After Investing in Business | 3577 | ||
Additional Cash in Balance Sheet Compared to 2014 | 4299 | Additional cash coming in from better Deferred Taxes, TWC, Cash Management etc; |